Alfa Romeo Owners Club of Australia Forum proudly hosted by AROCA Victorian Division
December 05, 2008, 06:21:59 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: Please edit your forum profile to set your AROCA State Division.  See this post for more information.
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1] 2 3
  Print  
Author Topic: 2003 156 jts selespeed - opinions  (Read 3289 times)
Alfa_alchemist
Newbie
*
AROCA Division: New South Wales
Posts: 18


View Profile
« on: March 02, 2008, 11:42:19 AM »

hello Alfa friends

this is my first post on this forum because I'm interested in purchasing a 156 jts selespeed (face-lift model). Now this is a short story:

the 156 in question is going for sale below the market value because the previous owner has blown the engine (55k on the clock) and the dealer selling it has reconditioned the engine - they had it at a higher price but because of no interest shown from the customers, they put the price right down.
 I am going for a test drive in a few days and according to the dealer the car runs perfectly with no issues.
Now I want your opinion guys - would this be a high risk purchase? I've heard the horrific stories regarding the jts enigine's reliability (i doubt the timing belt has been done on this engine - but I would do that straight away anyway) How expenisive is the jts enigine to maintain - average cost of timing belt service?
Is the selespeed in these cars better that the ones in the older ts engines?

thank you
Logged
TurboGTV
Full Member
***
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 158



View Profile
« Reply #1 on: March 02, 2008, 04:44:40 PM »

Quote
Now I want your opinion guys - would this be a high risk purchase? I've heard the horrific stories regarding the jts enigine's reliability (i doubt the timing belt has been done on this engine - but I would do that straight away anyway) How expenisive is the jts enigine to maintain - average cost of timing belt service?

This is very much a how low is a piece of string question.....  Since it has 55,000 on it, and the engine was blown, I'd suspect the timing belt may have been thrown and caused the failure - in which case the belt would have been changed.  60,000km is the interval for cambelts on those motors I'm pretty sure, in which case if the belt DIDN'T fail, then the belt SHOULD have been changed anyway - Especially since the car is new enough to have to be sold with a used car warranty by law, a smart dealer won't take the chance on that sort of thing.

You don't mention who the dealer is, and whether they are an Alfa dealer, or just a generic used car seller.  An Alfa dealer would hopefully not take the chance on a belt thats only 5,000km short of its schedule when they have the motor apart, it would be a stupid exercise in cost cutting for the cost of the parts to them.

Like I say, a 156 is new enough that by law it must be sold with a used car warranty (3 months/10,000km? not sure) at minimum, and if you're lucky you may even find it to still be under new car warranty.  If it at all concerns you that something isn't right, then purchase an extended warranty (usually offered by an independent company) for it, and make sure you keep up to date on the services which are required to keep the extended warranty valid.

As far as cambelt cost - the Alfa Romeo Australia website quotes a special of $452.65 for the parts to replace a cambelt, plus 3.5 hours of labour (generally charged out at about $100 an hour, but could be more depending on dealer).

http://www.alfaromeo.com.au/default.asp?action=article&ID=18265
Logged
Alfa_alchemist
Newbie
*
AROCA Division: New South Wales
Posts: 18


View Profile
« Reply #2 on: March 02, 2008, 09:29:43 PM »

thanks for the quick reply TurboGTV, regarding the dealer they are not an official alfa dealer - they are just a general used car dealer for european cars (they also supply parts for the european vehicles).

Well after i take a test drive I will know more details about the car but I'm just affraid of what might have been the cause of the engine to blow up at such a low k's - is this an unfortunate trait of the jts engines even with the good maintenance? Are there any tell-tell signs of a crapy jts engine with a first drive?

Another thing I'm worried with is the selespeed's reliability - I know the actuator has been revised on the facelift models (2003 -) but how reliable is it now cause almost every older model selespeed has failed at some point - I can't seem to find any owner experiences with the new selespeeds.

Anything else i should pay attention to?

thanks 
Logged
Alfa_alchemist
Newbie
*
AROCA Division: New South Wales
Posts: 18


View Profile
« Reply #3 on: March 03, 2008, 04:50:52 PM »

Ok guys I have taken the Alfa for a half an hour test drive today.

There seem to be no obvious mechanical issues with the car as the engine was pulling strongly (and it was a hot day with the aircon on).
The selespeed gearbox takes some time getting used to and is best when used in the 'manual' mode. The 'city' mode is a bit of a shocker -the gearbox is desperately trying to find the right gear for the right situation but most of the time it seems to decide on the wrong gear, jerking alot between lower and higher gears (its not your regular, smooth auto, thats for sure).
But I can get used to it in the manual mode (I still have doubts about its long term reliability so it would be great if somebody can share some owner experiences with these new, revised selespeeds).

The salesman told me that the cause of the engine blowing was a timing belt failure (you were right 'TurboGTV'), which they replaced and fully reconditioned the engine. They also give 3 months warranty.

Now there is one thing that kind of bothered me - when I first started the engine I popped the bonnet open to have a look at it and see how it works and there was a bit of a knocking/rattle noise coming from the engine (like a diesel but with the volume turned down).
As the engine wormed up, the noise almost disappeared but it was still notisable if you put the ear close to the engine - is this common for a JTS engine or could it be a sign of more trouble ahead?
Logged
TurboGTV
Full Member
***
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 158



View Profile
« Reply #4 on: March 03, 2008, 07:21:26 PM »

Quote
Now there is one thing that kind of bothered me - when I first started the engine I popped the bonnet open to have a look at it and see how it works and there was a bit of a knocking/rattle noise coming from the engine (like a diesel but with the volume turned down).
As the engine wormed up, the noise almost disappeared but it was still notisable if you put the ear close to the engine - is this common for a JTS engine or could it be a sign of more trouble ahead?

With my comment here, I'm making a complete stab in the dark, as I haven't yet tinkered with any late model Alfas, and I'm not sure what the innards exactly consist of, but IF they still use direct actuation from the cam to the valve (IE. solid cam followers), then its possible that the slightly looser clearances at cold when some of the oil has drained away from the head would cause a tapping nose until the engine warms up and the clearances close up a bit.

BUT, as I said, thats just a stab, and without hearing the noise myself I shouldn't even begin to theorize as to the cause.  If you are still interested in this car after your drive, then my advice is to look up an independent Alfa specialist in your area who deals with the later cars, and get them to do a thorough inspection/appraisal.  If that all checks out good, but you still have concerns about it lasting long term, grab yourself an extended warranty when you buy the car (be sure to read through the conditions carefully though, some basically only pay out if the earth span backwards while a blue moon was shining).

I'm a bit peculiar I suppose, in that I believe every model of car has its nightmare issues and expensive failures, so I go on the theory: Find the car you want, then find the best example you can, and smile.  If its going to hit the fan, it will, and it doesn't matter which make or model of car you're driving, it will still happen. 

Talk to any mechanic who specialises in any particular make of car (be it Japanese, European or Australian), and ask them what goes wrong, and they'll generally sprout off a list of expensive common problems, usually followed by "they're a heap of &%*$!".  Doesn't mean every car that comes through their door is blown up, doesn't even mean that over 1% of the cars that go through the door have these faults.
Logged
Doug Gould
Jr. Member
**
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 97



View Profile WWW
« Reply #5 on: March 03, 2008, 08:05:22 PM »

The selespeed bothers me a little. My 156 is manual and I'm not a fan of selespeed, but I have driven a number as loan cars. I don't like selespeed because my brain doersn't work that way, not because of any deficiency in the system. I have never had a car hunt for gears in city mode. The change can be abrupt, but I have never experienced one hunting for the correct gear. I'm also a little suspicious about a CAM belt going at 55k. The replacement interval is 60k and manufacturers generally place a large safety factor on this. If it legitimately broke early - why didn't alfa replace it under warranty? All the service guys that advertise with the club are good guys, I'd be taking it to the closest one for a check.

There is a ticking noise than can occur as a result of some part of the engine breather system doing something. There is an Alfa Service bulletin on the issue.

Doug Gould
Logged

08 159 JTS
07 Brera
85 GTV6
72 Montreal
65 2600 Sprint
60 VW Beetle
TurboGTV
Full Member
***
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 158



View Profile
« Reply #6 on: March 03, 2008, 08:36:44 PM »

Quote
If it legitimately broke early - why didn't alfa replace it under warranty?

2003 model, and if it had the same warranty as the 159s seem to be offered with, its a 3 year/100,000km - whichever comes first.  Generally manufacturers won't deal with anything outside their specified window (not just Alfa).

Not just that, but on the Alfa Romeo Australia website where the 'special' on cambelts is, it states 60,000km OR 36 months as the interval for cambelt changes.  Which would have made said car SOL for warranty claims.

Also note this extract from the same page:

"Most car manufacturers recommend replacement of the timing belt at a predetermined time or mileage and strongly recommend that replacement occurs on or before the recommended intervals, whichever occurs first.

The belt also should be replaced prior to the manufacturer�s stated limits if it has been damaged or contaminated by an outside influence, fluids or foreign matter.

If the vehicle is operated in a harsh environment or susceptible to heavy infiltration of dust, sand or salt for example, then the belt�s integrity and condition should be periodically inspected and replaced if required."

Australian weather is usually considered to be a harsh environment  Undecided
Logged
Doug Gould
Jr. Member
**
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 97



View Profile WWW
« Reply #7 on: March 04, 2008, 10:44:19 AM »

Forgot mine had the 5 year Alfa warranty they did as a promo. The point still remains that driven nicely the belt should last 100,000km or more. There are plenty of old Alfa's doing just fine with time expired belts. My GTV6 would be one of them. So what was the previous owners driving style / maintenance regime? If the previous owner hurt the engine - what other bits are also in pain? Note that Australian trade practices law does not recognise time limits. Basically, as far as the law is concerned a fault is a fault is a fault.

Doug
Logged

08 159 JTS
07 Brera
85 GTV6
72 Montreal
65 2600 Sprint
60 VW Beetle
Paul Gulliver
Jr. Member
**
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 57



View Profile
« Reply #8 on: March 04, 2008, 11:37:47 AM »

Not changing the timimg belt on a 156 every 60,000 is just like playing russian roulette. You are deferring maintaince that has to be done (cost of changing belt $800 to $1,000). But risking a $5,000 to $10,000 engine repair bill. I know from personal experience. Belt broke on  my 156 about 5 years ago. I had opted to wait 80,000 as per the book . It broke in the carpark at work starting the engine (bent all the exhaust valves, $3,500 repair bill). Imagine what you can break & damage if it lets go at freeway speeds. 
Logged

Paul Gulliver
2006 Black Alfa 159 2.2 JTS
1979 Silver Alfa 116 2.0 GTV
1973 Red Alfa 105 2.0 GTV
Scott Farquharson
Hero Member
*****
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 882



View Profile
« Reply #9 on: March 04, 2008, 03:45:36 PM »

Couldn't agree with Paul any more emphatically - belts must be changed every 60k - the risk isn't worth it.  Did one on mine at 60k - same - bent valves - the lot.  Don't risk it.  This is a well know issue and there are meny examples of it happening.
Logged

Scott Farquharson
www.malvern-group.com.au/dulux
Group C/A Dulux GTV6
Group S Alfetta GTV 2.0L (new project)
156 Selespeed
75 Twinspark
TurboGTV
Full Member
***
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 158



View Profile
« Reply #10 on: March 04, 2008, 06:18:00 PM »

Quote
The point still remains that driven nicely the belt should last 100,000km or more. There are plenty of old Alfa's doing just fine with time expired belts. My GTV6 would be one of them.

The older cars seem to be much easier on belts by reputation, although they too have been known to break.  I believe the earlier (75) twinsparks may even still have used timing chains?  For whatever reason, whether it be design or the tension they operate under, the 156/147 cars seem to have a tendency to chew belts, and going on the posts so far, perhaps even the 60,000km interval is too much?  Maybe a 40,000 interval may end up more economical (compared to an engine rebuild!).
Logged
Alfa_alchemist
Newbie
*
AROCA Division: New South Wales
Posts: 18


View Profile
« Reply #11 on: March 04, 2008, 06:19:28 PM »

thanks for your advice guys

now I'm stil interested in purchasing of this car but as some of you have advised me, the best course of action would be to bring an alfa specialist with me next time I have a look at the car.
This way he can give me his opinion regarding the mechanical state of the car, especialy the engine.

The issue is how do I bring the specialist with me - I live in Sydney (Liverpool area) and there aren't that many (if any) specialised alfa repairers here. The best option would be to take the car to the closest official Alfa dealer for the full check up, but ofcourse I would have to own the car first before I could bring it there (you leave the car for a whole working day for inspection - $150) and they can't leave the alfa premises even if you pay them.

I dont personaly know any alfa mechanics and I don't wanna bring some general Joe Blow mechanic who probably never worked on the jts engine in his life. Do you have any recommendations?
Logged
TurboGTV
Full Member
***
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 158



View Profile
« Reply #12 on: March 04, 2008, 06:48:50 PM »

Quote
The issue is how do I bring the specialist with me - I live in Sydney (Liverpool area) and there aren't that many (if any) specialised alfa repairers here. The best option would be to take the car to the closest official Alfa dealer for the full check up, but ofcourse I would have to own the car first before I could bring it there (you leave the car for a whole working day for inspection - $150) and they can't leave the alfa premises even if you pay them.

If the selling dealer won't drop the car down to a specialist of your choice, or permit you to take it there yourself, then its time to walk away.
Logged
Alfa_alchemist
Newbie
*
AROCA Division: New South Wales
Posts: 18


View Profile
« Reply #13 on: March 05, 2008, 06:11:57 PM »

Following your advice TurboGTV, I have asked the salesman to book the car for the full check up at Alfa dealer.
He agreed to it and the car is booked for this Friday after which they will give me a full report on the car and recommendations of what needs to be fixed.

Now this is where it gets a bit complicated - I told salesman that in case anything needs to be urgently fixed, the cost of that repair should be taken off the price of the car (I would leave the car at the alfa dealership so they can fix it).
He suggested that the price stays the same but anything that needs fixing will be fixed by them (their company is part used car lot, part repair shop for european vehicles) cause the costs from official alfa dealership are usually very high.
He also offered a full one year warranty on engine, gearbox and electrics. Is this a good deal?
Logged
TurboGTV
Full Member
***
AROCA Division: Victoria
Posts: 158



View Profile
« Reply #14 on: March 05, 2008, 08:36:06 PM »

Quote
Now this is where it gets a bit complicated - I told salesman that in case anything needs to be urgently fixed, the cost of that repair should be taken off the price of the car (I would leave the car at the alfa dealership so they can fix it).
He suggested that the price stays the same but anything that needs fixing will be fixed by them (their company is part used car lot, part repair shop for european vehicles) cause the costs from official alfa dealership are usually very high.
He also offered a full one year warranty on engine, gearbox and electrics. Is this a good deal?

This is where the juggling act really begins.  While if his workshop does the job, it will be cheaper, will it also be done 'on the cheap'?  Realistically, it should be reasonable nick given the age and kms, especially as it must be sold with warranty and RWC.  One very important thing is to make sure that you get an unwatered down report direct from the Alfa dealer. If there are issues, and you let the seller resolve them, it can be a good idea to run the car back through the dealer to check that the issues have been satisfactorily repaired.

I can't remember what the required warranty for a used vehicle is by law, it does usually state it on the information sheets they hang in the windows of cars on a lot (The ones that give previous owner details, price, kilometres etc), but I believe 1 year is possibly more than is required.  You'd want to pin down in writing the conditions of warranty to see that there aren't any 'no pay' type clauses, and squeezing a longer term out of him would always be good - maybe you could twist his arm into 18 months.

Ultimately, to answer the question you actually asked  Embarrassed, while the safest option is to have the Alfa dealer who is independent to the sale do any repairs which may be required on YOUR payroll (as you know they will be done properly), if you can squeeze some additional reassurance out of the seller in some form, then you're probably doing pretty well.  It's all down to your negotiating skills!
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.4 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC
Joomla Bridge by JoomlaHacks.com
Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.122 seconds with 21 queries.